Baby
and Toddler Books Authors
I fear that baby and toddler books are
encouraging prescriptive parenting. We think we can find the answers we
are looking for in the many books out there.
Some
of the following leading authors of baby and toddler books each offer us answers
to the many questions we have.
When
my son Jamie was 5 months
old I took him to his first swimming
lesson. I had seen babies swimming under water and I was really keen to
have my new wee babe do just that. We first time mothers all looked on
in horror however when the teacher suggested that we put our babies
heads under in that very first lesson.
“The babies are fine with
going underwater,” said the teacher, “It is
usually the mothers I have to talk into it!”
So here was the challenge –
would we listen to the teacher, to this
‘baby swimming expert’ and dunk our babies, or would we listen to our
motherly instinct and take our babies home immediately and NEVER return
to the pool with them again?
This is what happens I think
when mothers open these prescriptive
parenting baby and toddler books looking for answers to their much
sought after questions. They dip into the book with their pre conceived
and idealistic ideas and come up coughing and spluttering when the
expert suggests they do something that just doesn’t feel
right.
I believe this
is how we, as first time parents, should read these books. We should
read them with an air of caution. We are the mother of our baby. We are
with them 24/7 and we have our motherly instinct to guide us. At times
we just merely need to have our thoughts affirmed for us. At other
times we need to be given a whole new way of looking at our babies.
Maybe they are a lot more capable than we really understand.
Well
I did it, I have to say.
I decided to trust the swimming teacher
and was totally thrilled to see my 5 month old baby happily swim
underwater from the teacher to me.
From that day on Jamie proved to me
that he was a total fish and loves to swim. I will always be grateful
to the teacher for guiding me on this occasion and encouraging me to
let him swim underwater, something I thought he would take months to
learn.
Several authors of baby and
toddler books strongly oppose each other.
Each author offers advice and guidelines on a variety of topics from
feeding to sleeping. Gina Ford for example recommends a strict routine
with parents leading the baby. While Dr. Sears’s belief in attachment
parenting encourages parents to be baby led.
As a new parent you may be
unsure what your
parenting philosophy is. My suggestion to you is only ever use the
books written by these ‘experts’ as guides. If you are having concerns
with your baby sleeping, then read the section on sleep in each book
and see which one feels right for you. Each family is different and
each baby is different. It is hard to imagine that any one baby and
toddler book would
be a good ‘fit’ for any one baby or toddler.
|